Looking for a sweet addition to the Thanksgiving dessert table? These cuties will fit right in!
Order Your Holiday Cookies Now!
Small Batch. Big Flavor.
Missy's Sugar Shop is all about small-batch sweets that taste every bit as good as they look. From decorated sugar cookies and cake pops to drop cookies and rotating seasonal treats, everything is made fresh with quality ingredients and plenty of attention to detail.
Made in Sun Prairie, WI, with local pickup for customers throughout Madison and the greater Dane County area. Decorated sugar cookies are also available for shipping.
Whether you're celebrating something special or simply craving something sweet, there's always a good reason for cookies!
Cake Pops
Cake on a stick | Happiness on the go
From classic favorites to fun seasonal flavors, there's always something sweet on the menu! Enjoy my year-round favorites or watch for limited-edition flavors and festive designs during the holidays.
Available for local pickup in Sun Prairie, WI.
Fresh From the Oven
There's always room for a good cookie! From tried-and-true favorites to fun seasonal flavor combinations, my drop cookies are baked in small batches with a little something for everyone. Check back often to see what's new!
Follow Me on Instagram!
Want to be the first to see my latest cookie designs? Hear about my presales and popups? Get info on where you can find me and my cookies at local markets in the Dane County area? Then use your phone to scan the QR code, or click the button and give me a follow over on the 'gram!
Spooky season is here, and I’ve got the treats covered! Cookies and cake pops are available for local porch pickup in Sun Prairie October 29 & 30.