Small Batch. Big Flavor.

Missy's Sugar Shop cookies are a buttery, vanilla and almond flavored shortbread-like sugar cookie, with fresh vanilla royal icing. Your cookies are always made fresh to order, specifically for you, and I would love it if they were a part of your next holiday, special occasion, celebration, or just those times when you need a sugar fix!

To see my most updated availability, click on any listing and scroll through the dropdown menu of dates. Unfortunately, I am completely booked with orders for any earlier dates not listed.

Shamrock, pot of gold, leprechaun, rainbow, st patricks day cookies

Luck o' the Irish

Shamrocks, corned beef and cabbage, leprechauns, parades, green beer... these are just a few of the things that come to mind when we think of St. Patrick's Day. I say we add cookies to that list!

Shop Collection
easter chocolate bunnies, easter basket, easter eggs, easter egg hunt easter cookies treats, easter morning

Hoppy Easter

Chocolate bunnies are so passé! How about you fill those Easter baskets with cookies. And trust me... they are waaaay less messy!

Shop Collection
first trip around the sun cookies, astronaut, saturn, first birthday, rocket, balloon bunch, space birthday cookies

"Houston, we have a one year old."

Adorable space-themed treats for those little ones celebrating their first birthday. And if it's their second birthday... then "Two the Moon" cookies seems to be in order!

Shop Collection

Follow Me on Instagram!

Want to be the first to see my latest cookie designs? Hear about my presales and popups? Get info on where you can find me and my cookies at local markets in the Dane County area? Then use your phone to scan the QR code, or click the button and give me a follow over on the 'gram!