Small Batch. Big Flavor.

Missy's Sugar Shop offers soft and buttery-vanilla sugar cookies in crisp shapes and piped with fresh vanilla royal icing. Your cookies are always made in small batches and fresh to order, specifically for you, and I would love it if they were a part of your next holiday, special occasion, celebration, or just those times in between when you need a sugar fix!

While whimsical designs are my specialty, custom design requests are welcome!

My cookies are made with the finest ingredients: butter, sugar, eggs, vanilla bean paste, vanilla emulsion, cookie nip, salt, flour, meringue powder, corn syrup, powdered sugar, and food coloring gels. And while an allergen may not be listed in the ingredients, my cookies are made in a kitchen containing known FOOD ALLERGENS, and prepared with equipment that processes, but not limited to wheat, eggs, milk, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, and various fruits and vegetables.

Cookies come individually heat-sealed in a cellophane bag for freshness.

To see my most updated availability, click on any listing and scroll through the dropdown menu of dates. Unfortunately, I am completely booked with orders for any earlier dates not listed.

trick or treat, haunted house. pumpkin treat bucket, grim reaper, ghost, halloween cookies

So Cute, It's Scary

It's never too early to start thinking of my most favorite time of the year... HALLOWEEN! Whether you need treats for the trick-or-treaters, a Halloween party, or a spooky something for yourself, we got you covered!

Shop Collection
First Trip Around the sun cookies, first birthday cookies, space balloons, astronaut, rocket, moon, saturn, sun cookies

"Houston, we have a one year old."

Adorable space-themed treats for those space cadets celebrating their first birthday. And if it's their second birthday... then "Two the Moon" or "Two Infinity and Beyond" cookies seems to be in order!

Shop Collection

Main Squeeze

Easy-peasy lemon squeezy...

Just kidding. Finding the "one" can be tricky, time-consuming, and wrought with angst.

But you what IS easy? Eating cookies!

Shop Collection

Follow Me on Instagram!

Want to be the first to see my latest cookie designs? Hear about my presales and popups? Get info on where you can find me and my cookies at local markets in the Dane County area? Then use your phone to scan the QR code, or click the button and give me a follow over on the 'gram!