Cookies for Every Occasion

Missy's Sugar Shop cookies are a buttery, vanilla and almond flavored shortbread-like cookie with fresh vanilla royal icing. And I'd love it if they were a part of your next holiday, special occasion, celebration, or just when you're in need of a sugar fix!

To see my most updated availability, click on any listing and scroll through the dropdown menu of dates. Unfortunately, I am completely booked with orders for any earlier dates not listed.

Merry & Bright

Fa la la, Ho Ho Ho, and Jingle Jangle Jingle! Cookies are the perfect gift for that "I have no idea what to get them" person in your life. Think postman/woman, teacher, co-worker, secret santa, a friend of a friend, a hostess... Skip the gift card and send sweets instead!

Shop Collection

Year of the Rabbit

In Chinese culture, the rabbit represents strength, kindness, and courage. It also represents the moon as people say the moon's shadow looks like that of a rabbit. Whatever your birth animal may be, celebrate the lunar new year with cookies!

Shop Collection
Bananas for you, bananas cookies, banana leaf, heart valentines cookies

Love is in the Air

Are you tired of giving and receiving that same old heart-shaped box of chocolates? Then consider adorable, personalized cookies and take your V-day planning skills to the next! And remember, love is love is love!

Shop Collection

Follow Me on Instagram!

Want to be the first to see my latest cookie designs? Hear about my presales and popups? Get info on where you can find me and my cookies at local markets in the Dane County area? Then use your phone to scan the QR code, or click the button and give me a follow over on the 'gram!

Instagram